Fixing PHP Strict Standards: Declaration of method should be compatible

Updated: January 10, 2024 By: Guest Contributor Post a comment

Overview

Strict Standards in PHP are designed to ensure code quality and compatibility. When method declarations are not consistent with their parents or interfaces, you’ll encounter ‘Strict Standards’ errors. Mastering these standards is crucial for robust and upgrade-ready applications.

What Triggers the Error?

Before diving into specific solutions, it’s important to understand why this error occurs. In essence, it arises when a method in a child class or an implementation of an interface doesn’t match the signature of the corresponding method in the parent class or interface. The signature encompasses the method’s name, the number and type of parameters, and the return type.

Example of a Signature Mismatch


interface ShapeInterface {
    public function draw($color, $size);
}

class Circle implements ShapeInterface {
    public function draw($color) { // Error
        // Circle-specific drawing logic
    }
}

In the above example, the draw method in the Circle class does not match the signature specified in the ShapeInterface, resulting in a Strict Standards error.

Adjusting Method Signatures

To resolve this error, the method signature in the child class or interface implementation must be corrected to exactly match the signature in the parent class or interface.

Corrected Signature Example


// Corrected interface implementation
class Circle implements ShapeInterface {
    public function draw($color, $size) {
        // Circle-specific drawing logic
    }
}

With the method signatures now matching, the Strict Standards error will not be triggered.

Handling Optional Parameters

Problems often arise when dealing with optional parameters. While the order of parameters and the number of required parameters must match, optional parameters can vary as long as they don’t introduce incompatibilities.

Example with Optional Parameters


// Updated interface with an optional parameter
class Circle implements ShapeInterface {
    public function draw($color, $size, $border = 'solid') {
        // Circle logic with optional border style
    }
}

In this case, adding an optional parameter does not cause an issue as long as the required parameters are consistent with the interface’s declaration.

Type Hinting and Return Types

Type hinting and return types are also part of a method’s signature. Ensuring these match is necessary to comply with the Strict Standards.

Example with Type Hinting


interface ShapeInterface {
    public function draw(string $color, int $size):
    ShapeInterface;
}

class Circle implements ShapeInterface {
    public function draw(string $color, int $size):
    ShapeInterface {
        // Drawing logic
        return $this;
    }
}

Here, matching type declarations for parameters and the return type are used to satisfy the strict requirements.

Inheriting Constructor Signatures

Constructors in PHP classes, like other methods, must also adhere to compatibility rules. A common pitfall is when extending classes change the constructor parameters.

Constructor Signature Mismatch Example


class Shape {
    public function __construct($color) { ... }
}

class Circle extends Shape {
    public function __construct($color, $size) { ... } // Error
}

This inconsistent constructor will elicit a Strict Standards error as the signatures do not align.

Corrected Constructor Example


// A constructor that properly extends the parent's
class Circle extends Shape {
    public function __construct($color, $size = null) {
        parent::__construct($color);
        // Circle-specific construction logic
    }
}

The corrected constructor ensures compatibility by extending the parent’s signature and, if necessary, including additional parameters as optional.

Advanced Inheritance and Interfaces

Advanced cases might involve complex hierarchies or multiple interfaces. Even in these scenarios, each class or interface must carefully respect the strict typing and signature conventions to maintain PHP’s contract of predictability and reliability in object interactions.

Complex inheritance situations not only require matching signatures but also a deep understanding of class hierarchies and the purpose of each method.

Conclusion

Navigating PHP’s strict standards can initially seem challenging, yet it establishes strong practices that lead to more reliable and maintainable code. By adhering to method compatibility and understanding how method signatures propagate through inheritance and interface implementations, you can avoid common Strict Standards pitfalls and craft exemplary PHP applications.